Premiere date: 2008
Venue: Donmar Warehouse
Set in a manor house in rural Sussex, the story revolves around a highly dysfunctional upper-class family. Laurel (Felicity Jones) is a compulsive liar, attention-seeker, and a precocious fantasist with a fixation on setting fires. She is being raised by her overbearing grandmother, Mrs. St. Maugham (played by Margaret Tyzack), who has taken over Laurel’s upbringing out of spite because she disapproves of her daughter Olivia’s remarriage. The chaotic household is kept together by Maitland (Jamie Glover), a manic, neurotic manservant with a prison record as a conscientious objector.
Because Laurel is a handful, she successfully sabotages and drives away a steady stream of caretakers. Everything changes when the mysterious, highly reserved Miss Madrigal (Penelope Wilton) applies for the job. Despite arriving without any references, she is hired. Miss Madrigal is an expert botanist who instantly understands why nothing can grow in the grandmother’s barren, lime-heavy “chalk garden”—using it as a metaphor for how Laurel’s emotional growth is being actively choked out by her grandmother’s stifling environment.
Laurel attempts to bully and blackmail Miss Madrigal by digging into her secretive past. The tension reaches a boiling point when an old friend of Mrs. St. Maugham—a prominent Judge (Clifford Rose)—comes over for lunch. During the meal, details of a famous, past murder case are discussed. It is dramatically revealed that Miss Madrigal is actually Constance Doris Wakeland, a woman whom the judge had sentenced to death (later commuted to life in prison) for the murder of her stepsister.
Rather than destroying her standing, Miss Madrigal’s dark past gives her the ultimate leverage to save Laurel. Having experienced the ultimate consequences of a ruined youth, Madrigal forces Mrs. St. Maugham to confront her failures. When Laurel’s estranged mother, Olivia, arrives to reclaim her daughter, Miss Madrigal breaks through Laurel’s web of lies and encourages the girl to leave. Laurel chooses to reconcile and departs with her mother for a healthier life. Miss Madrigal chooses to remain behind in Sussex to finally cultivate and heal the barren chalk garden.

